How long will my order take?

Handling takes 1–2 business days and carrier transit is normally 3–7 business days, so most orders land in 4–9 business days. Tracking is emailed as soon as the label scans.

How much is shipping?

Orders of $75.00 or more ship free inside the United States. Below that, a flat $3.99 covers packing and carrier handling, whatever the box weighs.

Do you ship outside the United States?

Not at present. We ship to US addresses only, including Alaska, Hawaii and territories the carrier serves.

Can I pick my order up at the shop?

Web orders are shipped, not held for collection. If you want to buy in person, come to 2264 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10035, United States during opening hours (Open Mon–Sat: 10:00–18:30 | Sunday: 12:30–17:30.) and buy across the counter instead.

Checkout accepts Pay with cards and more, Card, WeChat Pay, Airwallex - Express Checkout, Klarna and Afterpay. Card details are handled by the payment provider and never stored on this site.

Can I return something?

Yes — unused goods, within 30 days of delivery. If the mistake was ours, we pay the return postage. Full detail is on the Refund and Returns Policy page.

How fast are refunds?

We issue the refund within 5–7 business days of the return arriving. Your bank then takes its own one to five days to show it.

Can I cancel an order?

Yes, before it is picked — usually within about 12 hours on a business day. After dispatch it becomes a return.

The card form belongs to our PCI DSS compliant payment provider. This website never sees a full card number.

How do I reach a human?

Email support@beautysupplyny.shop and you will get a reply within 1 business day, or call (212) 427-3881 during shop hours (Open Mon–Sat: 10:00–18:30 | Sunday: 12:30–17:30.).

East Harlem · 3rd Avenue at 124th

Jewelry bought <em>to be given away</em>

Pendant necklaces, birthstone hearts, stacking bracelets and boxed gold-plated sets — the case a neighbourhood shop keeps filled because someone always has a birthday this week.

Shop the case See what is boxed today

Jewelry bought <em>to be given away</em>

Moissanite Heart Pendant Necklace Sterling Silver Everyday $126.62

Square Halo Moissanite Pendant Necklace in Sterling Silver

Peridot Rose Heart Necklace Sterling Silver - I Love You Forever

Prices from: $9.98 – $198.97
In the catalogue: 14 items
Departments: 4

From the journal

All articles

How a small case gets filled

A gift has to survive the first month

A jewelry case in a shop this size holds maybe forty lines, so each one is chosen against everything it pushes out. Plating that greens a wrist, a clasp that fails, a chain that kinks — those come back across the same counter they were sold at, which is a very effective way of learning what to stop buying. What is listed here is what has stopped coming back.

Read our story